The Edge That Wasn't
All 81 experiments › #46

#46 — FIFO 2-box trail sweep (X3c_2_5)

2026-05-20 (Session 065)
Verdict: mixed · 🟡 mixed — halves backtest p/d for execution robustness; later refuted in paper
Widening the FIFO-Trends trail from 1 box (5p) to 2 boxes (10p) keeps GBP_JPY/USD_JPY walk-forward-positive at ~35/33 p/d while clearing the spread floor that killed the 1-box trail live.

Hypothesis — what it tests

Does a wider 10-pip (2-box) trailing stop make the FIFO-Trends P&F edge survivable under real spread and slippage, where the 5-pip 1-box trail was consumed live?

Description

After live FIFO-Trends deployments on account 013 died to 1-bar whipsaws (the 5-pip 1-box trail left only +2.1 pips over GBP_JPY's 2.9-pip median spread), this experiment reran the exact same b=5, r=1 configs with trail_d=2 — a 10-pip trail giving a +7.1-pip effective floor. GBP_JPY_ft2 (35.3 p/d OOS, 47% WR) and USD_JPY_ft2 (32.7 p/d, 46% WR) both passed walk-forward, though OOS p/d dropped roughly 50% from the 1-box results (71.6/68.5) because a wider trail means fewer exits and more drift per trade; EUR_JPY_ft2 failed WF outright at +5.9 p/d. Both passing configs were added to the fx-fifo-paper service (R7 consistency check 7/7 PASS) to watch the trail% exit split before any live redeployment. The Session 087 epilogue was negative: the ft2 variants were the worst paper performers (GBP_JPY_ft2 -274p, USD_JPY_ft2 -156p) and the whole FIFO paper book was stopped at -627.3p/849 trades with the standing instruction not to redeploy FIFO-Trends in any trail form.

Key result

GBP_JPY_ft2 35.3 p/d OOS (11,943 trades, 47% WR, WF PASS); USD_JPY_ft2 32.7 p/d (14,549, 46%, PASS); EUR_JPY_ft2 +5.9 FAIL; ~50% p/d drop vs 1-box (71.6->35.3); trail floor +7.1p vs +2.1p; paper epilogue GBP_JPY_ft2 -274p, USD_JPY_ft2 -156p

Indicators

P&Ftrailing stop (2-box)column-SMA exit (X3c_2_5)n_min prior-column filter

Algorithms

grid searchwalk-forward validationNumba JIT backtestR7 live-replay consistency test

Code

Interactive version (search, filters, figures): the experiment explorer.

← #45 GBP_USD small-box P&F sweep#47 PantasticSMA indicator screen →
This page is one experiment from the audited record behind the book The Edge That Wasn'tget the book · about the project.